World watching as NZ decides on ivory trading ban


By Fiona Gordon, The New Zealand Herald

Date Published
The world will be watching as New Zealand’s Select Committee of Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade today considers the merit of a petition from an Auckland-based teacher, Virginia Woolf, asking the government to ban the nation’s booming trade in elephant ivory and destroy its confiscated ivory stockpile.
“Only a truly global movement can end the slaughter of elephants,” Wildlife Conservation Society President Cristian Samper says, stating that such a decision by New Zealand would “show that your nation has stood up against poaching and trafficking and told the world that ivory consumption is unacceptable”.
Reports from US intelligence agencies and the UN show that profits from ivory trafficking are fuelling crime, corruption and violence in fragile African democracies and financing organisations that threaten security.
Samper’s view is echoed by Humane Society International President and CEO Andrew Rowan. “New Zealand’s close proximity to numerous biodiversity hotspots and hubs of illegal wildlife trade in the Asia-Pacific region make it an important ally,” he says.
Rowan considers publically destroying New Zealand’s seized ivory as an opportunity to assert regional and global leadership by becoming the first country in the region to do so, and to prohibit ivory trading. He adds that this would be a “symbolic gesture for New Zealand to show resolve in tackling wildlife trafficking”.
On the ground in Africa, African Wildlife Foundation (AWF) CEO Patrick Bergin says: “I cannot stress enough the crisis we are facing with regard to the survival of the African elephant.”
The AWF is asking every country with ivory to destroy it and every country that allows ivory trading to ban it. Bergin is of the belief that the moves “will systematically dismantle the infrastructure and incentives supporting the illegal trade and remove the very notion of ivory as a tradable commodity”.
Bergin also notes that it is the legal trade of ivory that is contributing to the demise of Africa’s elephants, providing a convenient cover for the illicit ivory industry.
Last month, New Zealand authorities laid charges relating to 31 pieces of elephant ivory. The nation witnessed its first ever conviction for illegal ivory trading last year.
Earlier this year, the International Fund for Animal Welfare raised concerns about the internet-based trading of endangered species products, including ivory, in New Zealand in their report Click to Delete.
Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) Executive Director Mary Rice explains that her organisation has more than 30 years’ experience investigating and exposing the international illegal ivory trade.
The EIA has formally acknowledged their strong support for advocates pressing New Zealand to adopt a ban on all ivory trade and to dispose of government-held ivory stockpiles.
According to Tanzania Association of Tour Operators Chairman Peter Lindstrom, the loss of elephants in Tanzania, and Africa as a whole, will deprive many people of jobs, reduce a source of government revenue that plays a large part in the national economy, and see the most iconic of land mammals driven to extinction.
With regard to New Zealand potentially crushing its confiscated ivory stockpile and banning the ivory trade altogether, Lindstrom says that “any gesture, however small, helps what we hope will be a groundswell that will move others to do the same”.
WildAid, whose ambassadors include Leonardo DiCaprio, Sir Richard Branson, Edward Norton and Jackie Chan, also supports the calls for more action by New Zealand.
WildAid Executive Director Peter Knights says that New Zealand has an opportunity to “set a precedent for ivory-consuming nations by implementing a complete ban on the ivory trade in, to and from the country”.
Just a few days ago, United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Administrator Helen Clark commented on the crisis: “Protecting elephants, rhinos, and other wildlife used to be mainly about habitat protection; now it also involves tackling the drivers of highly organised crime that has led to a massive slaughter of Africa’s iconic species.”
During a recent visit to Kenya, Clark signed a partnership agreement between the UNDP and Kenya’s First Lady Margaret Kenyatta on work to protect elephants.
Virginia Woolf, who led the petition considered today, says that world-renowned conservationist Jane Goodall “chose to remind us during her visit to New Zealand that every ivory bracelet, pendant or trinket represents a dead elephant and a total ban on the sale of ivory is the only way forward”.
With such clear international support, Woolf is hopeful the committee will “not just shelve the petition but instead take decisive and positive action” based on its recommendations.